Comparison Players for Mat Gamel

Mat Gamel, a third baseman in the Brewers organization, is threatening a 56-year-old Florida State League record with his month-long hitting streak. Gamel has flown under the radar relative to higher-profile prospects in the organization such as Ryan Braun and Yovani Gallardo, but he may finish the 2007 season as one of the Brewers' top two position prospects.

Who are the most similar hitters between the ages of 20 and 22? I restricted my search to hitters at the same level of competition and looked at key attributes such as contact rate, walke rate, and isolated power. Rather than give the false sense of precision with similarity scores, I will simply list all the significantly similar players in terms of "best case" and "worst case" trajectories after age 22.

Best Case
Matt Holliday
Nick Markakis

Median
Juan Tejeda
Scott Thorman
Mike Vento

Worst Case
Shaun Boyd
Chris Bass
Tripper Johnson
Bobby Malek

Matt Holliday's performance in 2000 and 2001 strongly resembles the kind of hitter Gamel is now, and he represents the best-case scenario for Gamel. Holliday has developed into an All-Star caliber power hitter, but it's worth noting that his size and power potential were more highly regarded at age 21. Markakis also compares nicely but the former first-round pick was a much more high-profile prospect at the time.

Several of the less optimistic trajectories involved players who stalled at Double-A when they struggled to hit for power while playing high-competition fielding positions such as first base and left field. This is a relevant risk factor for Gamel because he has been remarkably error-prone at third base and will likely move down the defensive spectrum in the future.

BallHype: hype it up!

Comments

1
you're not a fan of similarity scores, i take it?
Posted by Anonymous on July 06, 2007
2
Not really. I haven't seen any implementation where a difference of 10 similarity score 'points' has any interpretable meaning.
I'm open to new ideas regarding sim. scores, however.
Posted by Chris Constancio on July 06, 2007
3
Theres one thing that alarms me of Gamel is his lack of power this year. As a result, I havent picked him up in any dynasty leagues yet.
Do you think we should ignore his lack of power now thinking that he might develop it later on?
Posted by chilltownsdiddy on July 07, 2007
4
Well, it's definitely a big risk factor as he will struggle to make the majors if he has to change positions and can't hit for power.
On the other hand, he's in a pitcher-dominated league (remember Ryan Braun also struggled to show much power when he was with Brevard County). And Gamel is hitting plenty of extra-base hits - just not many home runs.
Posted by Chris Constancio on July 07, 2007

Please note that only registered users can contribute comments.

Current Reports

Sponsor


Login




Create Your Account
 

Players in the News

Organization Resources

RSS | PLAYER VIDEO | PLAYER LINKER
ABOUT FIRSTINNING | CONTACT US